During the week of June 29
th – July 4
th, I attended a Christian Rock festival of music in Bushnell, IL, called Cornerstone. This was an oftentimes-peculiar experience for me, as I don’t identify myself as a Christian.
To understand why I don’t identify myself with Christianity, it probably helps to know the area in which I live. I come from one of the many small towns in the Midwest, where Christianity – and almost no other religions – are the path of choice. My town has a population of 4,900 people and fourteen distinct churches – no synagogues or temples or any houses of other religions. We are a community of followers of Christ.
This was fine by me for most of my childhood. Neither of my parents were from the area, and both were raised Catholic. We didn’t attend the Catholic church in town, however; we attended a much more liberal church, part of the Disciples of Christ. Read up about the Disciples of Christ here: http://www.disciples.org/AboutTheDisciples/tabid/67/Default.aspx
I believed in Jesus throughout most of my childhood and indeed spent long hours talking to him in middle school when I was depressed. But I also spoke at length to the character of Martin the Warrior from Brian Jacques’ Redwall books, as well as the other assorted literary and movie characters that peopled my imagination. I saw Jesus on exactly that level: a fictional character from a book, someone who existed only in my head. And at some point in seventh grade, I simply ceased to believe.
I’m not sure exactly what happened here. We stopped attending church when I was twelve, so I’m sure that helped. Neither of my parents were firm believers, and they saw a lot of close-mindedness amongst the Christians of our town – something they didn’t like. By the time I turned thirteen, I’d begun to see the close-mindedness, too – and I hated it. I’d always been a tender child, and I have never, ever believed in hating anyone. I have always suspected that one of the reasons I love villains so much is because, deep down, I hope that they can be redeemed and brought back to the side of good.
Many of the varied beliefs about Christianity did not allow for the diversity I’d been taught to respect. I was told by some friends that God had a book in which were written the names of those who would go to Heaven; and if your name was not in that book, you were going to hell. I couldn’t believe that. No, I thought, not the God I’ve heard preached about. He wouldn’t be that hateful. He couldn’t be.
Things got worse. We grew older, I returned to public high school after going to a private school for two years, and I encountered more and more hatred. God hates fags. Catholics are really pagans and are going to hell. That denomination is wrong; they’re actually devil-worshippers even if they proclaim to be lovers of Jesus, and they’re burning. It was everywhere, and I couldn’t escape it.
Another facet of the town I live in is its large Apostolic Christian community. Here is the official AC website, if you’ve not heard of them: http://www.apostolicchristian.org/
Apostolic Christians follow a pretty strict code, generally speaking – some churches are less restrictive than others. The one in my town is one of the most stringent in the area. Many of their practices aren’t well known to outsiders, because the community is extremely insular. Women generally wear long skirts and keep their hair up in buns, and are confined either to homemaking or small jobs – being Certified Nursing Assistants at the AC Nursing Home, secretarial work, teaching. There are still arranged marriages of a sort, and pressure to have many children.
ACs make up about fifty percent of our town’s population, I’d guess, and most of them are related to one another. As children, it was impossible to see who was Apostolic and who wasn’t, but when we became teenagers it suddenly became clear. Whenever they believe they are called, Apostolics join the church. Nothing unusual about that, except that they are required to withdraw from any and all extracurricular activities that they were previously involved in and thus, cut off most communication with their non-Apostolic friends.
I only had one close friend who joined the church; I still see her on occasion. I consider myself lucky that she wants to keep in touch, because most ACs wouldn’t bother. Another close friend of mine lost one of her best friends to the church, and it was one of the most painful experiences of her life. I dated a man in the Apostolic church, and that caused both of us considerable grief.
Growing up in an environment like this turned me off to Christianity. I realize that not all Christians are so closed off and hateful, but many of the ones I went to school with and dealt with at work were intolerant of “the other,” and my understanding of Christianity suffered because of that.
So I wasn’t particularly thrilled to be heading to a week of Christians and Jesus love. I went because my friends were going, and because I knew there would be lots of good music. And there was plenty of both – and a very new impression of Christianity waiting for me.
The first few days weren’t full of the indoctrination I’d expected, largely because everyone there is assumed to be Christian already. But by the third day I was beginning to see the religion everywhere. I listened to the lyrics of a screamo band and realized that they were howling, “I am not worthy of the body of Christ!” I saw people walking around wearing shirts that read, “Devil Music for Jesus” and “I <3 Hardcore Christian Girls”. Pro-life posters began going up; I realized that there was a tent with a three-hour-long worship service every morning.
It wasn’t until I went to see a band called Ember Days with my best friend Katie that it really hit me, though.
Ember Days is a New Zealand Christian Rock band (their Myspace is here: http://www.myspace.com/theemberdays). I think that not all of their music is based on Christianity, but the show they played for us was all gospel music. This was the first time that I’d really had to sit through a concert of music focused solely on Jesus and God. I was surprised at how comfortable I was with it. Instead of focusing on Jesus I decided to send prayers up to a generalized higher entity and enjoy the beauty of their music anyway.
I was uncomfortable for one reason primarily: I worried that Katie, who is a staunch Lutheran, would be trying to repress her desire to participate in the show because of my presence. Katie and I fought in the past about religion – in high school I told her I felt like she was constantly trying to convert me when I would not be budged, and later she told me she felt like she couldn’t say anything about her religion around me because she feared I’d be offended. By this point we’ve found a balance – I’ve even gone to church with her once – but nonetheless I was concerned. I didn’t want her to feel like she had to hold back just because I was there. I’m happy for her that her religion means so much to her and I would never want to interfere on that. I made sure to let her know this after the show, and everything was fine after that.
That night we went to a big concert at the main stage; the headliner was Relient K, one of my favorite bands. Between concerts, the emcee for the show came out and spoke of Jesus’ love and asked the people at Cornerstone to donate their time and money to a company called Compassion, which sponsors children around the world who need money for food, clothes, and education. They also spoke about human trafficking and what a huge problem it’s become, and the things we could do to right the wrongs we saw.
On the fourth day we went to the main stage again. One of the bands, in the middle of his concert, paused and told the crowd, “I just want to say that I’m tired of all the hate I see. I’m tired of turning on my TV and seeing people standing there with signs that say, ‘God hates fags.’ Last time I checked, my Bible said to love everyone!”
Yes! I cheered. Exactly!
“I just want to say,” he continued, “That we’re standing here to represent love. We’re not worth idolizing. We’re just a band. We’re imperfect people; we’ve made huge mistakes. Believe me, you don’t want to be like me. But Jesus, he knew what he was doing. And he told us to love everyone. So I want you to love everyone, to make friends with other people who you wouldn’t have expected to be friends with. I know it won’t be easy, and I know you’ll screw up – God knows I’ve done it enough – but I want you to try, for Jesus. It’s what he would have done.”
And that speech was one of the most powerful things I heard all week. I was truly moved by this singer’s devotion to Jesus’ idea of loving everyone, no matter what they’ve done. That’s something I’ve always believed in – and, of course, have never been perfect at.
That message of love continued. Everywhere we went, bands would finish their shows by saying, “Jesus was about love, and so are we. Come visit us after the show’s over, and whatever is troubling you, whatever problems you’re having, we’ll talk it over and pray with you.” One band even offered to give out their personal cell phone numbers and Myspace pages. There was an incredible bond there, trust and caring that I’ve never seen before in such a huge gathering of people.
It came close to converting me a few times, but it never hit the spot. God and I are in a constant struggle with one another. I’m always questioning Him/Her/It, because there are so many things that don’t make sense.
I won’t accept the answer “it’s part of God’s plan” or “God is beyond the grasp of mortal men.” I don’t think God has a plan. I certainly don’t want to worship a God who planned the Holocaust, the genocide in Darfur, slavery, war, starvation, and all the other horrible things that have happened and will continue to happen in this world.
And I don’t think God is beyond the grasp of mortal men, because most of the stories I see make God sound like a mortal man. This accusation is often leveled at Greek Gods, but the Christian God isn’t much different in my eyes. No, He doesn’t drink; no, He isn’t constantly lusting after women. He’s above that. But He is jealous of his people; he flies into a rage; he makes mistakes. (He has to wipe out all the people and animals with a giant flood because they’ve turned evil. How could that possibly have been planned?) And people say that we’re made in God’s image; saying that makes me see Him as one of us – more powerful, perhaps, maybe wiser, but fallible nonetheless.
At one point, the emcee at the main stage told us he’d often questioned why God would put horrible things on the earth. He told us he’d figured out the answer: “God wants us to do something about it.” It’s a test, essentially. But that doesn’t feel right to me. Why does God want to test us so much? He’s like a jealous girlfriend, constantly testing our faith and loyalty. If He was our significant other, we’d probably leave him for testing our fidelity so much and not just having faith in us.
“So what is it you actually believe, Auri?” you ask. The answer is rather complicated. My beliefs are always shifting, depending on what I’m studying or learning or experiencing. I haven’t identified myself with a specific religion since I was eleven or so.
What I believe in now is the power of story – the power to move people to action and to lead better lives through words. To me, the Bible is a book of stories put together and meant to spur its readers into action. Its power doesn’t come from its literal meaning, but from the underlying message of love, perseverance, and forgiveness. When you get stuck in the literal text, trying to follow all the hefty old rules without considering the time in which the Bible was written and by whom, and who put it together, etc., I think you lose most of what’s important.
My opinion didn’t change entirely from being at Cornerstone, but I did leave with a much rosier impression of Christianity than I’d had before. I’ve always hoped to see the love of Jesus in action, and I think it was in action at Cornerstone – even if I don’t necessarily believe in the specific person of Jesus. I’m grateful for the chance to see that love, and the chance to carry it around with me in the days to come.
Chatboard (4)